Go back
Replacement Conservatory & Flat Roofs

Barrell Tile Roof vs Flat Tile Roof: Which Is Best For My Home?

flat-tile-roof.jpg

Nobody wants to have major work carried out on the roof of their home, however if yours is in poor condition it’s probably time to get an entirely new roof. Ignoring the signs that your roof requires replacing is always a bad idea, so taking action is paramount. 

There’s a lot of things to think about when it comes to changing your roof. However, once you’ve decided that it’s time to take the plunge there’s a major question that you need to answer – barrel tiles roof vs flat tile roof: which is best for my home? 

As you might expect, there’s no single answer to this question. So, let’s take a look at the differences between flat and barrel tiles so you can make a more informed decision... 

What Are Barrel Tiles?

Barrel tiles are made from moulded clay that has been baked into shape. The clay’s density depends on the baking temperature and amount of time it’s been heated. There are several colours of barrel tiles, but most have an orange or terracotta colour.

Clay barrel tiles are made out of a material which is derived from natural earth, and this makes them easy to recycle and also environmentally friendly. Barrel tiles also have a number of other advantages. 

The tiles are more resistant in strong winds and they’re fire resistant which makes them a safer choice for any home.

barrel-tile-roof-vs-flat-roof1.jpg

Since more water is absorbed by flat tiles, they are more likely to develop stains and mildew over time. Another factor to consider is that absorbed water will made concrete tiles even heavier, putting additional pressure on your roof

What Are Flat Tiles?

Flat tiles are made from concrete – a mix of water, cement, and sand – which has been moulded under high pressure and heat. Flat tiles feature interlocking ribs or water locks on their edges to keep water out of your home. 

Flat tiles are also very resistant to fire, wind, and hail, and this makes them a good choice as a safe material on your roof if they are installed properly. Although they don’t have the natural air pocket that barrel tiles can offer, they can be used with flat roof insulation for a cosy and warm interior.

Barrel Tiles Roof vs Flat Tiles Roof – What Are the Main Differences?

There are a few key differences when comparing a barrel tiles roof vs flat tiles roof. These include:

Water Absorption 

A flat concrete roof tile will have water absorption levels of approximately 13%. Meanwhile, clay barrel roof tiles have levels of around 6%. 

Since more water is absorbed by flat tiles, they are more likely to develop stains and mildew over time. Another factor to consider is that absorbed water will made concrete tiles even heavier, putting additional pressure on your roof.

Weight 

A concrete flat tile will weight around 40% more than a clay barrel tile. This means that it’s harder for your roof’s structure to support the additional weight when you choose a flat tile roof.

barrel-tile-roof-vs-flat-roof2.jpg

Although both barrel tiles and flat tiles are very durable, barrel tiles have the edge when it comes to longevity. While flat tiles can last as long as 50 years, barrel tiles could last for more than a century if maintained properly

Shattering or Cracking 

In a cold climate, barrel tiles may shatter or crack because of the cycle of freezing then thawing which will take place. Flat concrete tiles won’t be so easily damaged by freezing temperatures and this makes them ideal for all types of climate.

Maintenance 

Flat tiles are heavier, absorb more water and have a higher chance of mildew forming and this makes them harder to maintain when compared to barrel tiles which experience virtually none of these problems.

Appearance 

Barrel tiles are made from clay which occurs naturally. This allows them to keep their original colour for years despite being exposed to the weather. Concrete flat tiles, on the other hand, due to their porous nature, have a greater chance of becoming stained and less aesthetically appealing over time.

Durability 

Although both barrel tiles and flat tiles are very durable, barrel tiles have the edge when it comes to longevity. While flat tiles can last as long as 50 years, barrel tiles could last for more than a century if maintained properly.

barrel-tile-roof-vs-flat-roof.jpg

As barrel tiles have a curving shape, they are designed to protect the roof’s underlayment. They also create a pocket of air which is ideal for isolating and insulating unwanted cold or heat from being transferred into the attic space of your home

Making Your Choice Between A Barrel Tiles Roof vs Flat Tiles Roof

With this information in mind, you’ll be better placed to make an informed decision about whether flat tiles or barrel tiles are the right choice for your home. 

However, whichever type of tiles you select for your home, ensuring that you choose the right roof insulation to go beneath them is essential to keeping your property warm and comfortable to live in.

Take the next step to super secure roofing today, by calling 0800 1700 636, or, alternatively, by simply clicking the button below!