Go back
Replacement Conservatory & Flat Roofs

Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles: Which Is Best For My Home?

 Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles: Which Is Best For My Home

The ideal roof type for your home depends on a number of factors, including the size, age, and style of your property. Above all, a roof should be durable, waterproof and provide insulation. 

According to the Energy Saving Trust, 40% of heat can be lost through an uninsulated roof. As well as the correct insulation, you need the right roofing to go with it. 

If you’re looking into replacing your current roof, because you’re renovating or maybe even building a property, you’ve probably come across the options of wood shake and shingles, but which should you choose? 

This article will answer your question of ‘wood shake roof vs shingles: which is best for my home?’ so you can easily make the right decision for your property.

It’s vital that you choose the right kind of roofing to work with your home, as this will ensure it endures for years to come, keeps the heat in, and matches the style of your home. Failure to choose a suitable and high-quality roofing material could leave you with serious and expensive problems to deal with down the line... 

 Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles: Which Is Best For My Home

In essence, both shakes and shingles perform a similar job. They are designed to create a waterproof and weather-resistant roof that will stand the test of time. High quality shakes and shingles can last for decades if given the right amount of care and the correct maintenance

Shakes and Shingles - What’s the Difference?

Shakes and shingles are both used for pitched roofs and are installed by being nailed onto an underlying layer of sheathing and layered in overlapping rows from the gutter upwards.

Wood shakes and shingles are not massively different from one another, but it’s important to be aware of the differences they do have to ensure you choose the right type for your roof.

Shakes are split from logs, often by hand, and are usually made from hardwoods like cedar; they’re finished in a thinner, tapered edge than what you would be likely to find in a shingle.

Shingles are sawn on both sides from a solid block of wood, and have a more even, block-like appearance.

In essence, both shakes and shingles perform a similar job. They are designed to create a waterproof and weather-resistant roof that will stand the test of time. High quality shakes and shingles can last for decades if given the right amount of care and the correct maintenance. 

Both are good options for your roof, but which one should you choose?

 Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles: Which Is Best For My Home

Shingles, on the other hand, offer a more sleek, uniform appearance as they are cut to match each other perfectly. This is largely due to the fact that shingles are made by machines, whereas shakes are traditionally crafted by hand

How to Choose Between Shakes and Shingles

Both are attractive; both are practical, but which one is best for your property?

Shakes have a more rough and ready appearance, and are split from thick pieces of wood, rather than shaped from larger blocks like shingles. These are ideal if you want a more rustic look for your property, perhaps if it’s a heritage building. 

Shingles, on the other hand, offer a more sleek, uniform appearance as they are cut to match each other perfectly. This is largely due to the fact that shingles are made by machines, whereas shakes are traditionally crafted by hand.

The UK tends to use shingles for historical reasons; in other parts of the world, such as the US and Canada, shakes are favoured. 

 Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles: Which Is Best For My Home

The performance of shakes and shingles is close to equal; however, shingles work out slightly more economical than shakes if cost is your main priority

Home Logic: Experts in All Things Home-Related

Whether you opt for shakes or shingles is completely up to personal choice; the most important thing is to make sure they’re installed onto your roof correctly.

As a leading home specialist, Home Logic offers all sorts of advice and tips for helping you make decisions on changing your roof, choosing appropriate insulation, installing a boiler, saving money on your energy bills and more.

As you will see from the outstanding five star reviews Home Logic has received on the Trust Pilot page, you could join one of the thousands of happy customers and finally achieve the home you’ve always wanted.

‘I thought Homelogic was 1st class. I was very impressed with everyone concerned. They were all very professional and left everything clean and tidy. Thank you so much.’
-    Mrs Carole Hulbert

At Home Logic, we’re dedicated to providing each and every one of our customers with the best advice and care they need when making big decisions for the home. For more information on roofing and other elements of your property, get in touch with one of our friendly advisers today by calling 0800 1700 636, or, alternatively, by simply clicking the button below!